33 Comments
User's avatar
CyndyC's avatar

There must be a story behind why you have no sweet potato recipe. To me, they are as essential as turkey and cranberries. No marshmallows for sure, but something simple like James Beard’s preparation with brown sugar and butter.

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

Haha I just…don’t like them that much! My preferred sweet potato preparation is baked whole with butter and maple syrup

Expand full comment
Alysia Macaulay's avatar

Hi! Is there a substitute I could use for the heavy cream?

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

Like a non-dairy sub? You could use broth and it just wouldn’t be creamy (but squash would be tender and cooked through)

Expand full comment
Francesca L's avatar

Cashew cream may work.

Expand full comment
Sararosa Davies's avatar

I plan on using Country Crock's plant based heavy whipping cream. It's a pretty on spot on sub and I have used it in savory dishes and sweet dishes before. Trader Joe's has a dupe of the Country Crock if you cannot find it.

Expand full comment
Eliza Davidson's avatar

Hi hi! Could you do the green bean casserole without mushrooms?

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

I think you’re better off with a different green bean recipe- the mushrooms are what sort of make the cream gravy taste as good as it does. Otherwise it’s onions green beans and cream- not as delicious IMO! Do you not like or is there an allergy?

Expand full comment
Eliza Davidson's avatar

more like a strong aversion (not mine!!)

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

I think….you should make it with the mushrooms. The person who doesn’t like mushrooms (a texture issue I’m guessing) can easily eat around them but will reap the benefits of how delicious they make the green beans 💅

Expand full comment
Eliza Davidson's avatar

thank you 🙏🙏

Expand full comment
Mary Beth O'Rouke's avatar

What do we think about the salad dressing and walnuts mixture on shaved Brussels instead? Got some people in my family with strong biases to Kale even though they’re wrong

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

I think would be great. Don’t tell them Brussels sprouts are same family as kale and taste similar 😂

Expand full comment
Ali's avatar

One question on the salad -Is there no olive oil in the dressing itself? Thank you for creating a perfect thanksgiving meal and plan for us as always!!

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

No! You use the oil from frying the walnuts at the end. I don’t really make emulsified vinaigrettes that often and prefer to finish a salad with oil instead

Expand full comment
robert's avatar

Love this edition of Thanksgiving Alison! . As a Canadian, our turkey party was a month ago but it’s still great to see your ideas leading up to Xmas. Remind your watchers to keep the stems of kale, chard and parsley. Chopped fine, they are flavourfull additions to stock or minestrone.

Expand full comment
Miriam's avatar

Alison- one catch, the green bean casserole doesn’t list out French’s onion under ingredients. I almost forgot to buy them at the store until reading through the full recipe so just wanted to flag to anyone who may miss it too!

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

Fixed! Thank you and sorry about that! Glad you didn’t forget 🙏🙏🙏

Expand full comment
Miriam's avatar

Thank you for your service!!!! You’re the only human on this planet that finally inspired me to cook and now I find myself picking recipes from your three books on a consistent basis. 💗

Expand full comment
Bailey Dunn's avatar

Thoughts on subbing out whole mushrooms for cream of mushroom soup in the green bean casserole recipe?

Expand full comment
Marcus Powers's avatar

Okay, I truly only have one question. Where are the adorable heart-shaped gingersnaps from Home Movies from?!

Expand full comment
Miriam's avatar

Alison are we able to make the green bean casserole on Tuesday (2 days ahead) instead of Wednesday (1 day ahead)? Before topping with the onions and baking?

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

Yeah absolutely! Should be totally fine

Expand full comment
A Mason's avatar

Should the broth for the stuffing be salted? I’m using homemade turkey stock, which is unsalted atm but am thinking I need to salt it up before it enters the mix

Expand full comment
Olivia V.'s avatar

Thoughts on basil instead of tarragon/mint for the honeyed walnut salad? I waited too long to shop and can’t find tarragon or mint anywhere!

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

Parsley and chives would be my pick!

Expand full comment
Larry Curran's avatar

Could I add in parsnips to the squash gratin? I am hoping to incorporate for a friend who loves them but tryyyyyyinggggg to not cook them as a separate dish and don’t want to use in a potato dish / potato sub (lol). Thanks!

PS as a believer in the power of bay leaves , Make bay leaf ice cream - it’s good!

Expand full comment
Brandi's avatar

I am currently making the pumpkin pie. Should I definitely wait for no jiggle? HAPPY THANKSGIVING

Expand full comment
Alison Roman's avatar

Wait for barely jiggling! It should not be liquid, but jiggle slightly like jello

Expand full comment
Brandi's avatar

Thanks for always helping and answering questions. Happy Thanksgiving! You're a gem.

Expand full comment
Katherine Walecka's avatar

Just made the potatoes with 3 lbs of Yukon golds and 2/3 c each of heavy cream and salt. The proportions felt right!

Expand full comment
Katherine Walecka's avatar

Good lord, 2/3 c of buttermilk not 2/3 c of salt. Skipped the sour cream topping and just added fish roe as garnish.

Expand full comment
Cecile Reuge's avatar

Finished my turkey and marinated a chicken using your exact same dry rub to go with the rest of my sides 🤤this tided us over on meal prep for the whole following week

Expand full comment